Acrylic and Plexiglass- 10 Best Comparison

By admin / May 30, 2023

Definition of Acrylic and Plexiglass

Acrylic: Acrylic refers to a type of synthetic plastic material derived from acrylic acid or its derivatives and is commonly referred to by its trade names Plexiglas, Perspex or Lucite. Acrylic’s trademark qualities include its transparency, clarity and glass-like appearance which have led it to be widely used across numerous applications including signage displays home decor automotive parts signage displays display boards home decor home decor automotive signs signage panels signage boards sheets rods tubes or even custom made shapes.

Plexiglass: Plexiglass is the brand name for an acrylic plastic. Composed of transparent thermoplastic manufactured using polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA), Plexiglass stands out due to its exceptional clarity, impact resistance, strength and shatterproof qualities – often making it suitable as an alternative for glass windows, skylights, safety barriers or protective shields that need shatterproof qualities. Plexiglass comes in different thicknesses so it is easily cut drilled or formed into desired shapes for applications requiring shatterproof properties such as windows skylights etc.

Composition and Manufacturing Process

• Composition of Acrylic: PMMA is derived from acrylic acid or its derivatives and can also contain additives like plasticizers, stabilizers, dyes or fillers to further increase properties or attain desired characteristics.
• Manufacturing Process of Acrylic: To produce acrylic products requires multiple steps including polymerization and shaping:
• Polymerization: Acrylic production begins with polymerizing methyl methacrylate (MMA) monomers using organic peroxide as a catalyst, to initiate its polymerization reaction and link its molecules together, producing long chains of PMMA polymer.
• Bulk or Solution Polymerization: Polymerization can be performed using either bulk or solution polymerization techniques. With bulk polymerization, an MMA monomer and catalyst are combined and heated, causing it to polymerize into solid acrylic sheets or pellets. By contrast, solution polymerization uses monomers dissolved in solvent solutions where polymerization reactions take place within these solutions, before being precipitated out as acrylic sheets or pellets for drying purposes.
• Shaping: Once formed, acrylic polymers can be easily transformed into various shapes such as sheets, rods and tubes for manufacturing applications or injection molded products. Sheet production utilizes melt extrusion by passing it through a die; once cool it can be cut or further processed. Alternatively injection molding or thermoforming processes may also be utilized to form customized products from acrylic resin.

Underestimated is that manufacturing processes vary according to both desired end product and manufacturing equipment used. Various brands or manufacturers may have proprietary processes or variations in composition of acrylic materials which they employ during their processes of creation.

Difference Between Acrylic and Plexiglass

There are subtle distinctions between acrylic and plexiglass, two commonly used materials:

1. Composition: Both acrylic and Plexiglass come from polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA). Plexiglass, is the brand name of a particular type of acrylic. Acrylic, on the other hand, refers to an entire category of materials, including various brands and formulations.
2. Clarity and Transparency: Both acrylic and Plexiglass provide excellent clarity and transparency. Plexiglass, however, is known for having exceptional optical clarity that often exceeds generic acrylic. It offers a greater level of light transmission and is therefore a great choice for applications that require absolute transparency.
3. Manufacturing Process: Acrylic and Plexiglass are manufactured using similar processes. Plexiglass, however, is usually manufactured with higher-quality raw materials and more controlled production processes. The meticulous manufacturing process is responsible for its superior optical and clarity properties.
4. Brand recognition: Plexiglass has become synonymous with acrylic of high quality. As one of the premier brand names in acrylic materials manufacturing, Acrylite(r) has long been associated with superior materials. Acrylic is a more diverse product and brand, which includes both generic and specialty materials.
5. Availability and Cost: Acrylic is more widely available, comes in a greater variety of colors and thicknesses and costs less. Plexiglass is more expensive than generic acrylic due to its superior optical properties and brand recognition. Cost differences can vary depending on brands, suppliers and grade or quality of material.

While the term “Plexiglass”, is used often to describe any acrylic, it actually refers to a brand of acrylic. It’s important to evaluate the requirements of your application when choosing between Plexiglass and acrylic.

Physical Properties

Physical properties of Plexiglass and acrylic materials play a pivotal role in their suitability for various applications.

Here is an examination of some key physical attributes for both materials:

1. Transparency and Clarity
   • Acrylic is transparent and clear, making it easy to see through. It is characterized by a high rate of light transmission, usually around 92%.
   • Plexiglass Plexiglass has an exceptional optical clarity. It is transparent and known for its transparency. It can often exceed the clarity of acrylic generics, with high light transmission rates that can reach 93-94%.
2. Strength and Durability
   • Acrylic is a good material for its overall strength and durability. It is impact resistant, but is more susceptible to scratches and can be brittle when compared to Plexiglass.
   • Plexiglass Plexiglass has a high level of impact resistance. It is also very strong. It is more durable and scratch resistant than generic acrylic.
3. Flexibility
   • Acrylic is flexible to a moderate degree. It can be bent and shaped to a certain degree without cracking. However, excessive bending may cause it to break.
   • Plexiglass Plexiglass is more flexible than generic acrylic. It is more flexible and can be shaped without cracking.
4. UV Resistance
   • Acrylic is resistant to UV radiation. It can be exposed to sunlight for a long time without any significant yellowing.
   • Plexiglass Plexiglass is a great choice for outdoor use due to its excellent UV resistance. It is less likely to yellow or discolor due to UV exposure.
5. Chemical Resistance
   • Acrylic is resistant to many chemicals and cleaning agents. Acrylic can be damaged by strong chemicals and solvents, causing discoloration or surface damage.
   • Plexiglass Plexiglass is chemically resistant, much like acrylic. Chemical resistance enables it to withstand exposure to an assortment of substances without incurring noticeable damages or discolorations.
6. Temperature resistance
   • Acrylic: Acrylic is a medium-resistant material to temperature, with a range of -20degC up to 70degC. (-4degF – 158degF). It can deform beyond these temperatures or start to lose its structural integrity.
   • Plexiglass Plexiglass is similar to acrylic in terms of temperature resistance, with a range typically between -20degC and 80degC. (-4degF and 176degF). It can withstand temperatures above 80degC without deforming.

The physical properties of acrylic or Plexiglass can vary depending on its grade, thickness and formulation. It is important to evaluate these physical properties when selecting the right material for an application.

Cost and Availability

The cost and availability of Plexiglass and acrylic can be affected by factors like brand, grade and thickness.

Here’s a comparison between their price and availability:

Acrylic:

• Acrylic is more affordable than Plexiglass. There are different price ranges available depending on brand, quality and thickness. Generic acrylic sheets are more affordable and suitable for budget-conscious projects.
• Acrylic is available in many places, including hardware stores, plastic specialty suppliers, and on-line retailers. Acrylic is available in different thicknesses, colors, and finishes. This allows for a variety of applications. Plexiglas is a common acrylic brand, as are Perspex Lucite and Acrylic.

Plexiglass:

• Plexiglass is more expensive than generic acrylic. Its superior optical clarity and brand reputation are often responsible for the higher price. There are premium-grade Plexiglass materials available for applications requiring the highest quality and clarity.
• Plexiglass can be purchased from a variety of suppliers, such as specialty plastic distributors or authorized Plexiglass Dealers. It may not be available in the same quantities as acrylic generic, but it is still possible to find it through online retailers or local distributors. Plexiglass products and sheets are available in various thicknesses and dimensions, making them customizable to fit specific project needs.

Before choosing between acrylic or Plexiglass, it’s essential that you consider both its cost and availability. Acrylic may be the more cost-effective option if budget is a major concern. Plexiglass may be worth investing in if you are looking for superior clarity and a brand name that is well-known. Before making a final decision, it’s best to compare the prices of different suppliers. Also, consider your specific application requirements.

Maintenance and Care

Both acrylic and Plexiglass require proper maintenance and care to maintain their longevity and performance. 

Here are some guidelines on how to maintain and care for these materials:

1. Cleaning Methods
   • To clean acrylic and Plexiglass, use a microfiber cloth that is lint free.
   • Remove any loose dirt or dust before using any cleaning product.
   • Mix mild soap with warm water.
   • Dip the sponge or cloth into the soapy solution and wipe the surface gently in a circle.
   • Remove any soap residue by rinsing the sponge or cloth with clean water.
   • To prevent water stains, use a dry, clean microfiber cloth.
2. Scratch Resistant:
   • Avoid using rough brushes or scrub pads as they may cause scratches.
   • Avoid contact with sharp objects or abrasive surfaces when handling acrylic and Plexiglass.
   • Avoid rubbing the surface too hard, especially when there are debris or particles that can cause scratches.
   • Check the surface regularly for scratches. Minor scratches can be removed using acrylic or plastic polish.
3. Avoid Harsh Chemicals:
   • Avoid the use of strong solvents, alcohol based cleaners, ammonia or abrasive chemical on acrylic or Plexiglass.
   • They can also cause discoloration or cloudiness.
   • Use a non-abrasive, mild cleaner formulated specifically for acrylic or plastic surfaces.
4. Repairs and Maintenance:
   • Apply a special acrylic or plastic polish to minor scratches and buff in circles until the scratch becomes less visible.
   • If you have deeper scratches or damages, contact a professional to discuss repair or replacement options.
   • Avoid placing hot items directly on acrylic and Plexiglass surfaces as they may cause warping or other damage.
   • Under heavy objects, use felt pads or protective coasters to protect them from scratching or indentation.
   • Use protective covers when storing or shipping acrylic or Plexiglass. Or wrap the items in soft, nonabrasive materials to avoid scratches.

Maintaining the appearance and clarity of acrylic and Plexiglass with regular maintenance will ensure its longevity. Following these guidelines will help you keep your acrylic and Plexiglass surfaces clean and clear.

Safety Considerations

It is vital to consider safety when working with acrylic or Plexiglass.

Here are some guidelines for safety:

1. Protect your eyes and skin:
   • When cutting, drilling or shaping, wear safety goggles to protect your eyes from flying debris and particles.
   • Wear gloves when working with sharp edges or tools to prevent cuts and abrasions.
2. Dust and Fume Control:
   • When working with acrylic or Plexiglass fumes or dust, use appropriate respiratory protection such as a mask or respirator. This is especially important when cutting or sanding.
   • To minimize airborne particles and fumes, work in an area that is well ventilated or use local exhaust ventilation.
3. Fire Safety:
   • Acrylic and Plexiglass can ignite in certain conditions.
   • Avoid exposing them to heat, open flames or sparks.
   • Use appropriate precautions when using heat to bend or shape and keep a fire extinguisher close by.
   • Use a Class ABC extinguisher to put out a fire that involves acrylic or Plexiglass.
4. Tool Safety:
   • Use plastic-specific tools when cutting or shaping acrylic and Plexiglass.
   • Use only safe equipment and tools according to manufacturer recommendations for proper usage and care.
   •  In order to minimize risks of accidents, make sure all tools are regularly maintained to maximize effectiveness and minimize disruption of work processes.
5. Handling and storage:
   • Avoid damaging acrylic or Plexiglas sheets by handling them with caution.
   • To prevent discoloration or warping, store them in a dry and cool place.
   • When storing multiple sheets horizontally, support them with the proper support so that they do not bend or crack.
6. Disposal:
   • Use local guidelines and regulations to dispose of acrylic and Plexiglass properly.
   • Incinerate acrylic or Plexiglass as they can emit toxic fumes.
   • Recycling or disposing of acrylic and Plexiglass according to local waste management guidelines.

Use the safety guidelines provided by manufacturers, wear appropriate protective gear, and be cautious when handling acrylic or Plexiglass.

Environmental Impact

Acrylic and Plexiglass have various environmental impacts which can be evaluated according to several variables. These include their production process and recyclability as well as the potential environmental harm.

Considerations regarding the impact on the environment include:

Raw Materials:

• Acrylic and Plexiglass come from fossil fuels that are non-renewable, such as petroleum and natural gases.
• These raw materials are extracted and processed in a way that has environmental impacts, such as greenhouse gas emissions or habitat disruption.

Manufacturing Process:

• Production of acrylic and Plexiglas involves energy-intensive processing, such as polymerization and shape.
• Carbon emissions and resource depletion are caused by the energy consumption in manufacturing.

Waste and Disposal:

• The availability and accessibility to recycling facilities can vary by region.
• Incineration or improper disposal of acrylic and Plexiglass may release toxic fumes that contribute to air pollution.

Durability and lifespan:

• Acrylic and Plexiglass are durable and can withstand extreme weather conditions. This reduces the need to replace them frequently.
• By reducing the amount of waste generated, their durability can help reduce environmental impact.

Recycling and Circular economy:

• Some acrylic and Plexiglass can be recycled, reducing the need for virgin materials and contributing to a more circular economy.
• It is important to verify the recycling guidelines and capabilities of local facilities.

Alternatives:

• Alternative materials such as bio-based polymers or glass may offer environmental benefits. These materials offer reduced dependence on fossil fuels as well as improved recycling.

It is vital to reduce waste, encourage recycling and look for sustainable alternatives in order to minimize the impact of acrylic or Plexiglass on the environment. Making educated choices regarding production, sourcing, and disposal can help minimize environmental impacts associated with products used.

Common Applications of Acrylic and Plexiglass

Acrylic Applications:

1. Signage and displays: Acrylic is used extensively in the sign industry to create vibrant and eye-catching signage. Acrylic is used for retail fixtures, point-of sale displays, and exhibition displays.
2. Home décor and furnishings: Acrylic is also used for home decor and furniture. It can be found in tables, chairs and shelves to give them a sleek and modern look. Acrylic is used in frames, decorative panels, vases and other home decor products.
3. Automotive industry: Acrylic is used in the automotive industry for headlights and taillights as well as instrument clusters and interior trim components. These applications are made possible by its excellent clarity and durability.
4. Medical and healthcare: Acrylic is used for medical and healthcare products including dental devices, surgical instruments and incubators.
5. Art and crafts: Acrylic is popular for art and crafts due to its vibrant colors and versatility. Acrylic is used in painting, sculpting, crafting and for creating different artistic pieces.

Plexiglass Applications:

1. Windows and skylights: Plexiglass can be used in skylights and windows. It is often preferred to glass, particularly in situations that require impact resistance. Skylights are also made of plexiglass to let natural light in.
2. Safety barriers and screens: Plexiglass can be used to construct protective barriers, including sneezeguards, safety barriers for factories, protective screens for hospitals, and barriers placed in public areas.
3. Aquariums and Fish Tanks: Plexiglass can be used to construct aquariums and tanks for fish due to its strength and transparency. It also has the ability to resist water pressure.
4. Optical glasses and lenses: Plexiglass is an adaptable material used for lens manufacturing on sunglasses, eyeglasses and devices designed to improve vision correction. It is lightweight and resistant to impact.
5. Aircraft windows: Plexiglass can be used to manufacture aircraft windows in the aviation sector. Its high strength and lightweight properties make it an ideal choice to maintain structural integrity and provide visibility for crew and passengers.

Acrylic and plexiglass materials both possess properties which make them suitable for various uses, depending on individual property needs and application needs.

Conclusion

Acrylic and Plexiglass are both highly adaptable materials used in an assortment of applications. While both share many similarities, there are distinct distinctions between the two materials. Acrylic refers to an entire category of materials while Plexiglass refers specifically to one brand of high-grade acrylic that stands out for its exceptional clarity and transparency, ideal for optical applications that demand clear-view displays. Meanwhile, Acrylic offers greater accessibility, affordability, and greater variety – which could make one an attractive option over its rival in certain instances.

Before selecting acrylic and Plexiglass materials for use, it’s essential to evaluate factors like transparency, strength, flexibility, UV resistance, chemical resistance, temperature resistance as well as cost and availability. Gaining knowledge of their physical properties as well as maintenance requirements, safety considerations and environmental impacts is vital in choosing an apt material to suit your unique requirements.

Proper care of acrylic or Plexiglass products is vital to their long-term durability and optimal performance. By considering all their pros and cons, making an informed decision that fits in with your requirements and priorities.